Skip to content

The Best Cozy Mystery Books to Read or Gift This Winter

By EIKNA Editors · Updated · 15 books

The best cozy mysteries for winter are Nita Prose's The Mistletoe Mystery, Mia P. Manansala's Blackmail and Bibingka, Ally Carter's The Most Wonderful Crime of the Year and Benjamin Stevenson's Everyone This Christmas Has a Secret. Below: 15 picks with setting and series order, new 2026 Christmas mysteries and classic Poirot.

Last checked: 23 October 2026.

A cozy mystery is the reading equivalent of settling into your favourite chair and immediately noticing something suspicious. Winter gives the genre its best backdrop: snowed-in inns, holiday dinners, small towns where everyone knows too much about everyone else.

These fifteen picks are gentle on violence and generous with charm. Each one tells you whether it's a standalone or where it sits in a series, so you can give it as a gift without worrying. It's part of our winter reading and book gifts guide.

Store links on this page are affiliate links (Amazon, Audible, Bookshop.org and Libro.fm). If you buy through them we may earn a small commission, at no extra cost to you.

  1. 1. The Mistletoe Mystery by Nita Prose

    Cozy Mystery · 2024

    Best for: Readers who want something short and festive

    A Secret Santa exchange at the Regency Grand Hotel leaves Molly the Maid unsure whom to trust, while her boyfriend keeps mysteriously disappearing. Nita Prose's Christmas novella is a quick, tender visit with a much-loved character. It works best if you've read The Maid, but it's gentle enough for a newcomer.

    Read more about The Mistletoe Mystery
  2. 2. Blackmail and Bibingka by Mia P. Manansala

    Cozy Mystery · 2022

    Best for: Readers who love food, family and community

    Lila's estranged cousin comes home to Shady Palms for the holidays, and then becomes the prime suspect in a murder. The third Tita Rosie's Kitchen mystery is full of Filipino food, nosy aunties and Christmas chaos. Start with Arsenic and Adobo if you want the full story.

    Read more about Blackmail and Bibingka
  3. 3. The Most Wonderful Crime of the Year by Ally Carter

    Cozy Mystery · 2024

    Best for: Readers who like a mystery with a rom-com streak

    Rival writers, one cozy and one thriller, are snowed in at a Christmas house party, and when their famous host vanishes from a locked room, they have to work together. Ally Carter's standalone is part whodunit, part enemies-to-lovers.

    Read more about The Most Wonderful Crime of the Year
  4. 4. Everyone This Christmas Has a Secret by Benjamin Stevenson

    Comic Mystery · 2024

    Best for: Readers who like clever, funny puzzles

    A magician's benefactor is murdered backstage, and every suspect is a professional illusionist. Benjamin Stevenson's Christmas mystery comes with clues laid out like an advent calendar. You don't need the earlier Ernest Cunningham books.

    Read more about Everyone This Christmas Has a Secret
  5. 5. Dead and Gondola by Ann Claire

    Cozy Mystery · 2022

    Best for: Bookshop lovers and snowbound puzzle fans

    During a blizzard in a Colorado mountain town called Last Word, a stranger is found stabbed in a gondola. The first Christie Bookshop Mystery is set around a bookshop called the Book Chalet. It's wintry rather than Christmassy, and a good series starter.

    Read more about Dead and Gondola
  6. 6. The Christmas Jigsaw Murders by Alexandra Benedict

    Mystery · 2024

    Best for: Puzzle lovers

    Edie, a puzzle-setter, is taunted by a killer who leaves jigsaw pieces with each victim in the week before Christmas. The first Edie O'Sullivan mystery from Alexandra Benedict, who has become the go-to writer for Christmas crime. Her new one, The Advent of Death, is out in the UK on 5 November.

    Read more about The Christmas Jigsaw Murders
  7. 7. The Christmas Murder Game by Alexandra Benedict

    Mystery · 2022

    Best for: Readers who love a treasure hunt

    On a snowy Christmas Eve, Lily returns to Endgame House for a family treasure hunt. The winner inherits the house, and the cousins start dying. A standalone from Alexandra Benedict.

    Read more about The Christmas Murder Game
  8. 8. Miss Winter in the Library with a Knife by Martin Edwards

    Mystery · 2025

    Best for: Classic whodunit fans

    Disgraced figures from the publishing world are invited to a paid Christmas murder-mystery game in a remote North Pennines village. Then the snow comes, and a real killer starts on them. Martin Edwards knows Golden Age crime better than almost anyone, and it shows.

    Read more about Miss Winter in the Library with a Knife
  9. 9. The Christmas Appeal by Janice Hallett

    Comic Mystery · 2023

    Best for: Readers who like unusual formats

    A body turns up on stage while an amateur theatre group rehearses its Christmas pantomime. Janice Hallett tells it entirely in emails and texts, set in the world of The Appeal. Short, sharp and very funny.

    Read more about The Christmas Appeal
  10. Cover of Hercule Poirot's Christmas by Agatha Christie

    10. Hercule Poirot's Christmas by Agatha Christie

    Classic Mystery · 1938

    Best for: Traditional detective fiction fans

    A tyrannical patriarch summons his family for Christmas and is murdered in a locked room. Agatha Christie's 1938 holiday classic, first published in the US as Murder for Christmas. An easy, satisfying gift for anyone who loves Poirot.

    Read more about Hercule Poirot's Christmas
  11. Cover of Rest Ye Murdered Gentlemen by Vicki Delany

    11. Rest Ye Murdered Gentlemen by Vicki Delany

    Cozy Mystery · 2015

    Best for: Readers who want Christmas all year

    In Rudolph, New York, it's Christmas every day, and a shop owner finds a journalist dead and must clear her baker best friend. The first Year-Round Christmas mystery is the coziest book on this list.

    Read more about Rest Ye Murdered Gentlemen
  12. Cover of Christmas Cupcake Murder by Joanne Fluke

    12. Christmas Cupcake Murder by Joanne Fluke

    Cozy Mystery · 2021

    Best for: Readers who want recipes with their mystery

    Hannah Swensen bakes holiday cupcakes in Lake Eden while protecting a man with amnesia found near her bakery. Joanne Fluke's books come with real recipes, which makes this one a fun gift for bakers.

    Read more about Christmas Cupcake Murder
  13. 13. Deck the Halls with Boughs of Murder by Jacqueline Frost

    Cozy Mystery · 2026

    Best for: Readers of the Christmas Tree Farm series

    In Mistletoe, Maine, new mother Holly finds a body among the petting-zoo reindeer. Jacqueline Frost's seventh Christmas Tree Farm mystery, new this October. Start the series from the beginning if you're new.

    Read more about Deck the Halls with Boughs of Murder
  14. 14. Murder at Mistletoe Manor by F. L. Everett

    Cozy Mystery · 2025

    Best for: Fans of classic closed-circle puzzles

    Twelve strangers are snowed in at a country hotel four days before Christmas, and one is found dead. F. L. Everett's mystery is published in the UK.

    Read more about Murder at Mistletoe Manor
  15. 15. Christmas Crimes at the Mysterious Bookshop by Otto Penzler

    Mystery Anthology · 2024

    Best for: Short-story readers and bookish gift-givers

    Thirteen Christmas crime stories, each partly set in New York's famous Mysterious Bookshop, from writers including Jeffery Deaver, Ragnar Jónasson, Laura Lippman and Anne Perry. Easy to dip into and easy to wrap.

    Read more about Christmas Crimes at the Mysterious Bookshop

Cozy Christmas mysteries at a glance

Setting, series position and how gentle each one is.

BookAuthorSettingSeries?Intensity
The Mistletoe MysteryNita ProseHotel at ChristmasMolly the Maid novellaCozy
Blackmail and BibingkaMia P. ManansalaSmall town, ChristmasTita Rosie's Kitchen #3Cozy
The Most Wonderful Crime of the YearAlly CarterSnowed-in house partyStandaloneCozy
Everyone This Christmas Has a SecretBenjamin StevensonTheatre at ChristmasReadable aloneCozy, comic
Dead and GondolaAnn ClaireColorado blizzardChristie Bookshop #1Cozy
The Christmas Jigsaw MurdersAlexandra BenedictWeek before ChristmasEdie O'Sullivan #1Cozy to moderate
The Christmas Murder GameAlexandra BenedictSnowy country houseStandaloneModerate
Miss Winter in the Library with a KnifeMartin EdwardsSnowed-in villageStandaloneModerate
The Christmas AppealJanice HallettAmateur pantoNovellaCozy, comic
Hercule Poirot's ChristmasAgatha ChristieFamily ChristmasPoirotClassic
Rest Ye Murdered GentlemenVicki DelanyChristmas townYear-Round Christmas #1Cozy
Christmas Cupcake MurderJoanne FlukeBakeryHannah SwensenCozy
Deck the Halls with Boughs of MurderJacqueline FrostChristmas tree farmChristmas Tree Farm #7Cozy
Murder at Mistletoe ManorF. L. EverettSnowed-in hotelUK editionCozy
Christmas Crimes at the Mysterious Bookshoped. Otto PenzlerBookshopAnthologyCozy to moderate

What makes a mystery cozy?

Look for an amateur sleuth, a close community and a puzzle at the centre. Cozy doesn't mean nobody dies; it means the violence stays off the page and the fun is in the investigation and the people. If you want darker, more suspenseful winter reading, try our winter thrillers and snowbound mysteries.

New Christmas mysteries for 2026

Four new holiday mysteries arrive this season. Deck the Halls with Boughs of Murder (6 October) continues the Christmas Tree Farm series. Peter Swanson's Do You See What I See? (6 October) is a 128-page Christmas puzzle at a Cape Cod estate, a little darker than most cozies. In the UK, Katie Lumsden's The Christmas Tree Murders (5 November) is a Victorian country-house mystery solved by a kitchenmaid, and Alexandra Benedict's The Advent of Death (5 November) brings back Edie O'Sullivan.

Lucy Foley's Murder at the Grand Alpine Hotel, an authorised Miss Marple novel set in a snowbound Swiss hotel, came out in September. It's a classic whodunit and would suit this list as well as the thriller one.

Classic Christmas mysteries

For traditionalists: Hercule Poirot's Christmas (1938) is the original holiday whodunit. Sophie Hannah's Hercule Poirot's Silent Night (2023) sends Poirot to a Norfolk hospital in December 1931. And Agatha Christie's Murder on the Orient Express, with its train stuck in a snowdrift, is the most famous snowbound mystery of all.

Choosing a cozy mystery as a gift

  • Pick a series starter or standalone when you don't know what they've read. Our table flags both.
  • Short reads win in December. The Mistletoe Mystery and The Christmas Appeal are both novellas, and the Mysterious Bookshop anthology is easy to dip into.
  • Match the setting to the person. Bakers get Joanne Fluke, bookshop lovers get Dead and Gondola, puzzle fans get Alexandra Benedict.

More ideas in book gifts for cozy readers and the main winter reading and book gifts guide.

How we chose these books

Every pick is set at Christmas or in deep winter and keeps the puzzle and the community at the centre. We checked authors, publishers, dates and series order against publisher, retailer and review pages, and we flag UK-only editions. We haven't read every book here; descriptions draw on publishers and published reviews.

Sources: Penguin Random House: holiday cozy mysteries, Penguin UK: the best Christmas murder mysteries, Kirkus on The Christmas Jigsaw Murders, Simon & Schuster UK: The Advent of Death, Bookreporter on Christmas Cupcake Murder and Bookreporter on Do You See What I See?.

Frequently asked questions

What are the best cozy Christmas mysteries?
The Mistletoe Mystery by Nita Prose, Blackmail and Bibingka by Mia P. Manansala, The Most Wonderful Crime of the Year by Ally Carter and Everyone This Christmas Has a Secret by Benjamin Stevenson.
What new Christmas mysteries come out in 2026?
Deck the Halls with Boughs of Murder by Jacqueline Frost and Do You See What I See? by Peter Swanson (both 6 October), plus, in the UK, The Christmas Tree Murders by Katie Lumsden and The Advent of Death by Alexandra Benedict (both 5 November).
What is a good short Christmas mystery?
Nita Prose's novella The Mistletoe Mystery, Janice Hallett's The Christmas Appeal, or Peter Swanson's 128-page Do You See What I See?
What is the classic Agatha Christie Christmas mystery?
Hercule Poirot's Christmas (1938), published in the US as Murder for Christmas.
Is a cozy mystery a good gift?
Yes, especially a series starter or standalone. Novellas and anthologies are easy to finish over the holidays.