As Many Souls As Stars
1592. Cybil Harding, daughter of a secret alchemist, was born under cursed stars. Destined to bring disaster to those around her, Cybil is trapped in a grand house with a mother paralysed by grief and a father willing to sacrifice everything in pursuit of magic. Miriam Richter is a creature born of shadow. Forged by the dark arts, she is doomed to exist for eternity and destined to be alone - consuming the souls of mortals for sustenance. Everything changes when Miriam meets Cybil, whose soul shines with a light so bright, she must claim it for herself. Miriam offers a bargain: she will grant Cybil reincarnation and the chance to change her stars in exchange for her soul. Thus begins a dance across centuries as Miriam seeks Cybil in every lifetime to claim her prize. But Cybil isn't inclined to play by the rules. As the two women circle each other, drawn together inescapably as light and dark, the bond forged between them grows stronger. In their battle for dominance, only one of them can win... but perhaps they can't survive without each other. Natasha Siegel's fantasy debut is full of transporting historical detail, with thrilling twists and an abiding, thought-provoking romance that feels at once epic and deeply personal. Ambitious, gothic, and magical, As Many Souls as Stars is about the lengths we go to protect ourselves, our legacy, and those we love.
About This Book
As Many Souls As Stars is an english literature romance novel by Natasha Siegel, first published in 2025 by Bloomsbury Publishing Plc. It runs 320 pages. Readers can expect enemies to lovers, star-crossed lovers; sweet heat; a slow burn and emotional tone.
At a glance
- Genre
- English literature
- Trope
- Reincarnation
- Heat
- Sweet
- Mood
- Slow Burn
- Published
- 2025
- Length
- 320 pages
Where to read or listen
Get As Many Souls As Stars by Natasha Siegel
These store links are affiliate links (Amazon, Audible, Bookshop.org and Libro.fm). As an Amazon Associate, Eikna earns from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you. Learn more.
Why You May Love This Book
You may love this if…
- An immortal shadow creature and a cursed alchemist’s daughter engage in a high-stakes bargain for a soul that spans centuries of reincarnation.
- Fans of The Invisible Life of Addie LaRue
- Readers who enjoy This Is How You Lose the Time War
- Yearning
- Features Reincarnation
This may not be ideal if…
- Readers who dislike reincarnation tropes
- Readers looking for a simple contemporary romance
- Those who prefer high-heat/erotica
The Romance
Tropes, dynamics, and the chemistry that drives this story.
Tropes
Relationship Dynamics
Details
Type: Gothic Historical Fantasy Romance
Pairing: F/F
Power balance: Unequal but shifting
Age gap: Eternal
How It Feels
The emotional landscape you'll move through while reading.
Mild comfort, high tension, high angst.
Heat Level
Based on available metadata and editorial review.
Who Is This Book For?
Best for
Reading mood
May not suit
Recommended audience: Adult
Content Guidance
The Story
Spoiler-Free Synopsis
Cybil Harding is born under cursed stars in 1592, trapped by her father's dangerous magical obsessions. Miriam Richter is an eternal being forged by dark arts who must consume souls to survive. When Miriam encounters Cybil’s uniquely bright soul, she offers a bargain: the chance for Cybil to change her destiny through reincarnation, with the cost being her soul at the end. As they meet again in various lifetimes, the hunter and the hunted develop a bond that transcends their original agreement, forcing them to choose between dominance and survival.
Central Conflict
The power struggle between Miriam’s predatory nature and Cybil’s defiance, set against an eternal bargain that binds their souls across lifetimes.
Setting
Spans from 1592 England through various historical periods across centuries.
Themes
Strengths
- Ambitious chronological scope
- Strong atmospheric writing
- Compelling high-concept premise
Consider before reading
- Multiple lifetimes may dilute individual character development
- Heavy gothic tone might be too dark for some romance readers
Similar Books You May Like
Books that share the romance DNA, tropes, and emotional arc of this one.

The Isle in the Silver Sea
Tasha Suri
Shared tropes: Reincarnation, Star-Crossed Lovers; Similar emotional intensity; Comparable spice level; Shared tone: Melancholy, Epic; Similar slow-burn pacing [evidence: tropes, themes, tones]

The Fox and the Devil
Kiersten White
Shared tropes: Enemies to Lovers; Similar emotional intensity; Comparable spice level; Shared tone: Gothic, Atmospheric, Melancholy; Similar slow-burn pacing [evidence: tropes, themes, tones]

Gideon the Ninth
Tamsyn Muir
Shared tropes: Enemies to Lovers; Similar emotional intensity; Comparable spice level; Shared tone: Gothic; Similar slow-burn pacing [evidence: tropes, themes, tones]

Fingersmith
Sarah Waters
Shared tropes: Enemies to Lovers; Similar emotional intensity; Comparable spice level; Shared tone: Gothic, Atmospheric; Similar slow-burn pacing [evidence: tropes, themes, tones]

All of Us Murderers
K. J. Charles
Similar emotional intensity; Comparable spice level; Shared tone: gothic, atmospheric [evidence: themes, tones]

Terrible Praise
Lara Hayes
Comparable spice level; Shared tone: Melancholy, Atmospheric [evidence: tones]

The Invisible Life of Addie LaRue
V. E. Schwab
Shared tropes: Star-Crossed Lovers, Soulmates; Similar emotional intensity; Shared tone: Melancholy, Atmospheric [evidence: tropes, tones]

All Together Stranger
Lara Hayes
Similar emotional intensity; Comparable spice level; Shared tone: Atmospheric [evidence: themes, tones]
Discussion Guide
Questions to deepen your reading experience or spark a book club conversation.
- 1
How does the central conflict shape the relationship between the main characters?
- 2
Which theme — Eternal soulmate — resonated most strongly with you, and why?
- 3
How does the setting influence the characters' decisions and their relationship?
- 4
How do the relationship dynamics evolve throughout the story?
- 5
Who would you most want to recommend this book to?
- 6
How did the pacing affect your reading experience?
- 7
Which aspect of the story did you find most compelling?
How This Profile Was Created
Eikna uses book metadata and AI-assisted analysis to create structured romance profiles. Public profiles are reviewed and approved by an editor before publication.
- Editor reviewed:
- Yes
- Last reviewed:
- August 30, 2026
- Confidence:
- Moderate confidence
- Profile version:
- eikna-public-book-intelligence-v1
About the Author
What Readers Say
No reviews yet
Be the first to share what you thought of this book.
Publication Details
- Publisher
- Bloomsbury Publishing Plc
- Published
- 2025
- Length
- 320 pages
- Language
- English
- ISBN-13
- 9781526684592
As Many Souls As Stars: quick answers
- Who wrote As Many Souls As Stars?
- As Many Souls As Stars was written by Natasha Siegel.
- When was As Many Souls As Stars published?
- As Many Souls As Stars was first published in 2025 by Bloomsbury Publishing Plc.
- What genre is As Many Souls As Stars?
- As Many Souls As Stars is an english literature romance novel, with enemies to lovers, star-crossed lovers.
- How many pages is As Many Souls As Stars?
- As Many Souls As Stars is 320 pages long.
- How spicy is As Many Souls As Stars?
- EIKNA rates As Many Souls As Stars as sweet heat.
Are you the author? Verify your author profile to manage this book.
This is my book — sign inWhere to read or listen
Get As Many Souls As Stars by Natasha Siegel
These store links are affiliate links (Amazon, Audible, Bookshop.org and Libro.fm). As an Amazon Associate, Eikna earns from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you. Learn more.
Want more books like this?
Let Lyra help you discover lesbian romance books that match your exact mood, favorite tropes, and reading style.
